Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Welcome to The Gang of Five | The Land Before Time. We hope you enjoy your visit.


You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


Join our community!


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
The My Little Pony - Friendship is Magic Thread; Its epic... trust me
Topic Started: Mar 7 2011, 07:16:15 PM (185,272 Views)
The Chronicler
Member Avatar
Bionicle fan of GoF
Even though I saw the early release of these two episodes nearly two months ago, I choose to wait until after their official US release before I shared my reviews on them.

(spoilers)
First episode, Fluttershy and Discord are enjoying yet another tea party at Fluttershy's place, and at some point in their conversation, Discord offers to host the next tea party the very next day. As he's out gathering supplies, he eventually comes to believe that a pony like Fluttershy might not like his highly chaotic home and lifestyle, so (with assistance from multiple Discords) he normalizes and organizes his house and his wardrobe.

When Fluttershy arrives (or rather instantly brought there by Discord), she's obviously suprised by how dull and boring everything is. Confusion suddenly turns to panic when Discord's lack of chaotic activity causes him to literally start vanishing out of existence, up the the point where he can no longer even snap his fingers to use his magic. I have to admit, it was fun to see Fluttershy going completely nuts with everything in an attempt to save Discord, and thankfully it actually worked. With Discord safe, Fluttershy tells him that she had really expected his house to be just as chaotic as it actually was. They later proceed with their tea party once Discord's house has been restored to is usual chaotic state

Second episode, when Apple Bloom brings home some pear jam she got from Grand Pear at the market, Applejack and Big Mac quickly hide it before Granny Smith can find out about it. Apple Bloom finds out for apparently the very first time that there's been a family feud between Apples and Pears, and she naturally asks why that is. Applejack and Big Mac admit they're just as clueless, since Granny Smith would always refuse to say anything whenever they had asked her, so the three Apple siblings decided to go ask the family historian Goldie Delicious (previously seen in the Season 4 episode Pinkie Apple Pie). The feud was largely a business rivalry between Granny Smith and Grand Pear, but their respective kids, Bright Mac and Pear Butter (nicknamed Buttercup when they first met), were the only ones to not get involved in the feud and even enjoyed spending time together. Once the Apple sibling realize those two are actually their parents, they're surprised that they're actually half Apple and half Pear.

Now, the Apple siblings decide to learn more about their parents. They first talk to Bright Mac's friend Burnt Oak, who tells them about how their father was an honest pony (much like Applejack). Next, they talk to Pear Butter's friend Mrs. Cake, who tells them not only about how their mother helped her to understand her special talent (much like Apple Bloom), but also about how their parents understood their love for each other. Finally, Mayor Mare talks about how, with the Pear family suddenly moving to Vanhoover, their parents didn't want to be separated, so they decided to get married right away, with a small and secret wedding (and much like Big Mac, they didn't want anything big and fancy). When Granny Smith and Grand Pear find out about it, Birght Mac and Pear Butter make it clear that they refuse to be separated. Grand Pear practically forces his daughter to chose between the Pear family and the Apple family... and she tearfully chooses to stay with the Apples. Grand Pear walks away furiously, and that's presumably the last time they ever spoke to each other.

With Grand Pear now back in Ponyville, the Apple siblings decide it's time to set aside all past differences and bring him and Granny Smith together with them. With Grand Pear expressing deep regrets for his past behavior, they all agree to finally come together as a true family, and they even get to see an entwined apple and pear trees their parents had planted on their wedding night.

The first episode was just fine like most others. The second episode, however, reveals so much backstory about the Apple family that we had wanted to hear about for so long, and does it so well, that I wouldn't be surprise if a lot of fans were to call it one of their absolute favorite episodes of all time (I know I certainly enjoyed seeing it).

(end spoilers)

Now that we are all finally completely caught up on all those early releases, I really hope that'll be the last we'll ever have to worry about that issue.

By the way, some more Equestria Girls shorts have been coming out lately, one yesterday evening and one more about to show this evening. (I've heard that this will be happening every weekend for the entire month of August, so I guess we'll have to wait and see if that turns out to be true.)
https://www.equestriadaily.com/2017/08/more...mer-shorts.html
https://www.equestriadaily.com/2017/08/anot...mmer-short.html
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
f-22 "raptor" ace
Member Avatar
yay
As I said when I first watched the Perfect Pear back when it was aired early. It is one of the best episodes of the series.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~REVIEW POST~

Okay, let's begin this double review. Starting with Discordant Harmony. Spoilers below.

Well, this was a fun and enjoyable episode. For such a simple thing as Discord hosting a tea party for Fluttershy, the writers sure made it work. Discord literally talking to himself, his shopping trip as a whole, the complete makeover of his place... Discord made so many mundane things enjoyable.

I do like how Pinkie Pie, THE expert in party planning, was there to help Discord at first, and she was totally right in the end. Fluttershy would have had a great time if Discord was just himself.

Then we get to Act 3, and boy do things get surreal. The fact that Discord NEEDS to have chaos around him for him to exist says a lot. It's almost as if he causes chaos as a survival mechanism. On top of that, we have Fluttershy acting out of character to save her friend. The lengths she goes to save her friend from vanishing in front of her eyes is a testament to their friendship. Heck, as a fan of Fluttercord, I welcome all they did here.

Very fun and enjoyable episode. Worth watching!


Now for The Perfect Pear.

Oh my gosh! This episode is AMAZING! This is an episode that honors the memory of the parents of The Apple Siblings. Bright Mac and Pear Butter loved each other so much, they were willing to defy their parents to see one another and dared to have a secret weeding just to be together in the end. They may not be among the living, but they will always be in the hearts of those who love them.

Also, the choice Pear Butter had to make. I do not wish this upon even my worst enemy. Choosing between the family you've loved all your life and the love of your life is a difficult decision and not one to be taken lightly. I cannot imagine the pain she felt being forced to make the choice she did. The feud started as a business rivalry and it led to this breaking point. I am still shocked it went this far.

However, let's talk about my thoughts on the fandom with this. I am utterly shocked by the fact that Applebloom's line of, "They may not be with us anymore.", a line used as a hint in media for confirming someone has passed on, didn't all but confirm them being dead in the minds of a number of them. I guess some people need to see a freaking tombstone and a line that confirms they've been dead this whole time just to finally give in! Ugh! Sometimes this fandom drives me up a wall.

Enough of that though. Anyways, I am also surprised with the ones they touched. Sure, we had a new character in Burnt Oak, but I never expected Mrs. Cake to be Pear Butter's best friend and Mayor Mare to be the one to officiate the wedding. Mrs. Cake especially came out of left field. It was indeed quite surprising.

Finally, let's talk about Grand Pear and Granny Smith in all of this. The fandom has called the both of them hypocrites, and they are not wrong. One could argue that they should not care about the kids that Bright Mac and Pear Butter had. However, the fact that Granny Smith loves her grandkids, despite the fact they are half-Pear, shows she was willing to put aside the feud to care for any member of the family. Deep down, it must have been difficult for her to do such a thing. She set aside her pride to raise her grandkids after the parents passed on.

Then, there's Grand Pear. An old stallion, who realized far too late that he was nothing but an old fool. Forcing his daughter to choose because of his pride. He regrets it deeply and wants to make amends any way he can. Now, he's trying to get to know the children his daughter had. He's setting aside his pride to get to know three ponies who are half-Apple.

Are they still hypocrites? Yes, but the fact they are making the right decision, makes it not matter.

I dare to say this is the best episode of Season 7 thus far. A great episode I would definitely watch again.


See ya next week for an episode that debates Friendship Lessons. :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Hypno
Member Avatar
GoF's resident Sharptooth fan
Discordant Harmony reminds me of the PS1 startup error known as Fearful Harmony :blink:
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~SUMMARY POST~

Tomorrow is the newest episode! Yep, no early release this time around. Get the summary below.

------------
Title: Fame and Misfortune

Summary: Twilight releases a book on all of the Friendship Lessons she and her friends have experienced. It becomes super popular and sparks a debate on which Friendship Lessons are the best ones.
------------

Now, due to me being out of town, I may or may not be able to see the episode when it airs due to not that great of internet. We'll see. On top of that, I may or may not be able to give the online post when it comes out. We'll see there too!

Until then, see ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~LIVE STREAM POST~

Good morning, internet! Today is another episode of pony! Today, the friendship lessons are at stake. Get the link to the Live Streams below!

Season 7 Episode 14 - Fame and Misfortune Live Stream

I have much anticipation for this one.

See ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~ONLINE POST~

Got to watching it and I'm surprised a certain someone hasn't posted yet. ;)

Anyways, here's the links.

Season 7 Episode 14 - Fame and Misfortune YouTube Version

Season 7 Episode 14 - Fame and Misfortune Daily Motion Version

Yep, it's been a while, but I finally have a YouTube Version of a pony episode. Knowing YouTube, it won't last long. :)

Anyways, will give my review tomorrow when I get the chance.

See ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
The Chronicler
Member Avatar
Bionicle fan of GoF
(spoilers)
After dealing with a friendship dispute between two random fillies, Twilight suddenly remembers the Friendship Journal that she and her friends wrote back in Season 4. However, it's in rather poor condition due to neglect, so Starlight offers to make fresh copies for them and their friends (using a spell she had developed for a certain "manifesto" her old evil self wrote). This and the recent incident with those fillies gives Twilight the idea to make many more copies and distribute them all over Equestria, in hopes that they can teach everyone about friendship lessons they had learned over the years. Once she gets approval from all of her friends, she goes through with her idea.

It isn't long before the results of this effort turn out in ways the Main 6 had not intended: Rarity is devastated that she is so disliked for her dramatic personality; Pinkie Pie is laughed at every time she says something, even when she's trying to be serious; Rainbow Dash is constantly surrounded by obsessive fans who won't leave her alone, not even when she has important weather duties; Fluttershy is accused of never actually learning her lessons on assertiveness; Applejack's home gets severely overcrowded by fans wanting to be part of her family; and Twilight just gets asked all kinds of random questions.

The unwanted attention become so problematic that Twilight's friends are practically forced to barricade themselves inside her castle. Twilight tries to reason with the crowd outside that she only wanted to share the journal's friendship lessons with everyone, but they stubbornly stick to their attitudes and beliefs. Not even a song is enough change their minds. Remarkably, Starlight tracks down the two fillies who had fought at the start of the episode and they reveal that not only did they read a copy of the journal, but the friendship lessons they learned from it actually made them closer friends. For Twilight and the others, that's good enough for them to say that the effort was worth it (despite the crowd still gathered outside).

I have to say, this episode was clearly meant to be a huge series of meta-jokes regarding fans of the show. I'm sure some of us are familiar with the stereotype that some fans obsessively watch certain episodes many times, frequently argue about who is "best pony", and almost never demonstrate the friendship lessons of some episodes.

One little detail I noticed is that the Cutie Mark Crusaders (apparently thanks to the sudden popularity they've gotten from the Friendship Journal) decided to start a so-called "Cutie Mark Camp", and based on what I've heard about the remaining episode summaries for the season, that could actually be foreshadowing an upcoming episode much later on.

I would also like to note that, since that journal was apparently neglected for quite a while, it seems that the last entries may have been from the end of Season 4, right before the Main 6 met Starlight Glimmer. Not only would that explain Starlight's unfamiliarity with it, but it would also arguably indicate that some details in the journal may be a little out of date (like the state of Fluttershy's assertiveness).

(end spoilers)

Anyway, it sure is nice to finally get back into the old routine of everyone seeing new episodes on the intended premier date. I'll definitely be looking forward to next week's new episode.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
f-22 "raptor" ace
Member Avatar
yay
Today's episode was a fun one indeed. You didn't need to get me anything for Christmas this year M.A. Larson. But thank you for this wonder wonderful episode.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~ONLINE POST~

Oh boy! What an episode! This was definitely good! Spoilers below!

I'm sure I didn't need the lessons of this episode shoved down my throat, but I know members of the fandom that do. This is one of those episodes where they make fun of the fandom and it's enjoyable to boot.

I mean, all of the comments the ponies gave on the Friendship Journal, I have seen every single one of them more than once in the fandom. (Even the whole "Twilight was better without wings" argument is still going on. Why can't some people just get over it already?) It has become a hostile place and I'm not sure how much more I can take before I demand some moderation to happen.

Anyways, back to the episode, it was pretty crazy. You had ponies who only wanted to preserve it, Rarity "stress sowing" one of the worst dresses I have ever seen, (Seriously, even though I have "no fashion sense", even I can tell it's bad.) Pinkie being laughed at ALL the time, Ponies staying at Applejack's, Fluttershy being harshly criticized on having to learn the same thing over and over and Rainbow being told how cool she is ALL the time. (She can't even have privacy in the restroom apparently.) Geez! Talk about craziness!

Even the song which is meant to drill the most important point of the episode doesn't sway these ponies. It makes me wonder just how they get rid of them in the end. (FimFiction, ahoy?) I would consider those two fillies that Twilight talked to are "true" fans to their book, but that's just me.


Great episode and worth watching.

Next time, we have a certain dragon and changeling meeting each other for the first time.

See ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
The Chronicler
Member Avatar
Bionicle fan of GoF
I forgot to mention the new Equestria Girls shorts that came out this weekend:
https://www.equestriadaily.com/2017/08/new-...time-short.html
https://www.equestriadaily.com/2017/08/anot...rls-summer.html

In addition, one of the already aired shorts is now available on Hasbro's official YouTube channel, so at least we can look forward to eventually seeing all of them there as well.
https://www.equestriadaily.com/2017/08/mlp-...ad-twience.html
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~SUMMARY POST~

Hello, everyone! Tomorrow is a new episode of pony with two certain characters returning. Get the summary below!

-------------
Title: Triple Threat

Summary: Spike accidentally invites Thorax and Ember to meet at the Friendship Castle on the same day. Due to an old feud between dragons and changelings, can Spike keep them away from one another throughout the day?
-------------

I'm sure shenanigans will ensue. It should be good.

See ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~LIVE STREAM POST~

Good morning, Internet!! Welcome to where the dragon waifu of the fandom finally returns, with a character we haven't seen since the first episode of the season also returns. Get the link to the Live Streams below.

Season 7 Episode 15 - Triple Threat Live Streams

As always, I'll post the online version later today and my review tomorrow.

Until then, see ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~ONLINE POST~

Well, that was not a good episode. I'll give more why during my review. For now, here's the link for the online version.

Season 7 Episode 15 - Triple Threat Daily Motion Version

I'll see ya tomorrow for my review, which I'm not looking forward to. -_-
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
The Chronicler
Member Avatar
Bionicle fan of GoF
(spoilers)
The episode begins with everyone in Ponyville getting ready to welcome Ember, but while Spike, Twilight, and Starlight are going over the checklist, Thorax suddenly shows up, and Spike suddenly realizes that he invited both Ember and Thorax on the same day and apparently never noticed such a scheduling conflict. Spike immediately assumes the worst and fears that dragons and changelings will not get along at all, so with some help from Twilight and Starlight, he decides to do everything he can to keep Ember and Thorax apart.

Naturally, shenanigans result. Twilight takes Thorax to the castle, but Spike accidentally convinces Ember to visit the castle as well. While Twilight bores Thorax with reading chairs, Ember's visit in the dining room takes an awkward turn due to dragons diet preferences for gems and crystals. Spike suddenly gets summoned by the Cutie Map to solve a friendship problem right in town (certainly didn't see that one coming), so while he heads out to find it, Twilight and Starlight swap places (so Twilight is now with Ember and Starlight is with Thorax), and without realizing the other's actions, they both take their companions out into town. A little later, Spike ends up listening to (and getting bored by) Thorax's many issues, while Twilight and Starlight together causes Ember to get confused by how similar they are (nice little meta joke there).

Inevitably, they do end up meeting, but the initial aggression is due to them both mistaking the other for trying to harm their friend Spike. A few words exchanged make them quickly realize their error before they could come to blows, and they both end up leaving Spike for seemingly not trusting them to get along.

Soon after (in the part of this episode that pleasantly surprised me), Thorax and Ember meet each other and they both end up offering helpful advice that the other desperately needed. Ember teaches Thorax how to be more assertive so he can better handle his new role of leadership, and Thorax teaches Ember that she'll be better able to make friends if she simply talked about her feelings. Using their respective lessons, they both confront Spike, who then apologizes for jumping to conclusions. With everyone finally reaching an understanding, Spike completes his Cutie Map mission (interesting to note that it sent him to solve a problem that he ended up causing in the first place).

Not a bad episode, in my opinion, though there were certainly moments of cringe, which I'm sure I've mentioned before that I'm never fond of. The old trope of keeping two individuals unaware of the other's nearby presence was rather predictable, so it was rather nice to see two things I was not expecting: Spike getting called by the Cutie Map, and Ember and Thorax end up solving their problems on their own without Spike's help at all. I would consider this among my favorable episodes, but not much else to say for it.

(end spoilers)

Edit: Almost forgot to mention, no new Equestria Girls shorts this weekend, but we did get one earlier this week:
https://www.equestriadaily.com/2017/08/eque...ails-short.html
Also, Hasbro's official YouTube channel recently added one of the earlier shorts, so I guess it'll be one every week we'll be seeing this.
https://www.equestriadaily.com/2017/08/hasb...ake-up-eqg.html
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~REVIEW POST~

I'll be making an announcement after this post on a little issue going on. For now, here's my thoughts on the episode. Spoilers below.

There is little doubt in my mind just how bad of an episode this one was. It contained missed opportunities, conflicts that weren't needed and a lesson that the show alone teaches.

We even have Spike be given the idiot ball and hold it through the entire episode. I really hate when a character is given the idiot ball. It just shows the writer being non-creative.

If anything, both Ember and Thorax themselves were good characters. They had problems that those alone would be better to talk about for the episode. To introduce and expand into.

Ember has such a problem with enforcing friendship into dragon culture, that it's proven to be ineffective. She's not used to receiving hugs and she misinterprets certain cultures. She's actually great for all of this. The core problem she has is that she was being TOO competitive. To the point where she was bullying other dragons. This could have been expanded upon and gone more in-depth. However, because of all that was just wasted time, it's all set to just a few minutes and the problem is solved far too quickly.

Then we have Thorax. He can sure ramble. On top of that, he's not that aggressive about his leader roles. He also has problems with converting changelings to the new way of feeding off of love. Some changelings are traditionalists apparently and making them change their ways proves to be difficult. This really could have been expanded upon too, but it seems they'll be saving it for a future episode.

Instead, we have the majority of the episode dedicated Spike freaking out for no good reason and trying to keep them apart to the point where he himself creates such a huge friendship problem that the map responds. Nice to see the map can even call Spike. However, I don't feel like this one counts because not only does he cause it, but the problem solves itself. I'm hoping for a real one in the future.

This was a bad episode. Only Ember and Thorax were good in it.


For what it's worth, I'm not seeing this one again.

Next time, camping trip!

See ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
So, now for my announcement. I've made a decision. I've chosen to block EqD's comment section from my computers. The mods there have proven to be ineffective in dealing with trolls to the point where they don't even bother. They've given the role of "mod" a bad name and I just don't want to deal with their continued disbelief of what Freedom of Speech entitles to.

Now, this will not effect me going there. I can still read their articles and link to what I want to. It's just the comment section I have a problem with and it's time I took care of this situation.

So yeah, nothing has changed for here. I just won't be posting on EqD anymore. It's just not worth it in the end.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~SUMMARY POST~

Sorry this is so late, but here's the summary for the newest episode that will air in the morning.

--------
Title: Campfire Tales

Summary: When the CMC's camping trip is ruined, Applejack, Rarity and Rainbow Dash tell them stories and they make the best out of the situation.
--------

I don't expect much from this episode, but hopefully it'll be good.

See ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~LIVE STREAM POST~

Well, here we are! The newest episode will air soon! Get the links to the Live Streams below.

Season 7 Episode 16 - Campfire Tales Live Streams

As always, I'll post the online link later today and my review tomorrow.

Until then, see ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
pokeplayer984
Member Avatar
Yes, that's a new Pokemon!
~ONLINE POST~

Well, that was fun! You'll find out why tomorrow. For now, here's the link to the episode.

Season 7 Episode 16 - Campfire Tales Daily Motion Version

My review comes tomorrow.

See ya later! :wave
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Silver Screen · Next Topic »
Add Reply

Modified version of the theme/skin created by "Jameswgw". Find more great designs at the ZetaBoards Theme Zone.